- What happened
- ABC15 reports an Arizona trooper said a driver went over 100 miles per hour, with lane drifting, driving on the median shoulder, the smell of alcohol, a refused breath test, and open containers. The report narrative carried an all-caps label saying it was generated with assistance from Truleo AI, a police report writing tool. Because the officer's own account wasn't in the filing to compare, Court Commissioner Daniel Fenzel said he couldn't meaningfully weigh whether AI wrote the allegations and found he couldn't determine probable cause. The driver was later charged, with arraignment set for November 12. Separately, an Arizona appeals court in September threw out a ten-year road rage sentence over an AI-generated victim impact statement, and the Arizona Supreme Court wants a status report on AI court standards by March 1, 2027. Phoenix Police have been piloting Axon's Draft One, which EFF said in July 2025 discards the first AI draft and doesn't record which parts the AI wrote. No specific error was identified in this report.
- The claim
- The report stated the words still reflect the officer's own observations.
- Austin's take
- Austin says the commissioner made the right call. A release isn't an acquittal, and a police report shouldn't have a mystery author. AI drafting is fine, but courts should get both the officer's account and the AI draft, with clear marking of whose words are whose.
- Why it matters
- As AI drafting tools spread through police departments, courts need to know who actually authored the facts they're weighing, or cases can stall.
- What to do
- If your local police use AI report tools, ask whether they keep the original draft and the officer's own account and show which parts the AI wrote.
From the Friday, November 13 show
Arizona court releases 100 mph DUI suspect over AI-assisted police report
AI-generated from the transcript