- What happened
- The Washington Post tested chatbots from six companies, asking about addresses in all 3,100 US counties. Microsoft's Copilot cited a small AI-built site called the Ballot Brief in three quarters of its answers. The Post found real errors on the site, including merging two different people named Robert Garcia into one profile, and fixes came only after the Post asked about them. A survey says two in five Americans have used AI for election information.
- The claim
- The Ballot Brief's founder says Microsoft's AI pointed to the site over 680,000 times in thirty days.
- Austin's take
- Austin says this is what you'd expect when chatbots handle current events: they can't rely on training data, so they search, and a site optimized for traffic can look like a trusted source. In his own test, both ChatGPT and Claude refused to say who to vote for but offered ballot info. ChatGPT's voice mode struggled to name candidates, while Claude gave better answers and compared candidates using their campaign sites. He doesn't think Claude cited the Ballot Brief for him but says he'd need to recheck.
- Why it matters
- Lots of people now ask chatbots about elections, and a single error-prone, AI-generated site can end up shaping a huge share of those answers.
- What to do
- Treat chatbot voting info as a starting point. Check candidate and polling details against your official county or state election site before you vote.
From the Monday, November 2 show
Copilot cited an AI-built voter site in 75% of answers
AI-generated from the transcript