- What happened
- Ars Technica tested Google's AI Mode on Wednesday and found that US users asking who won the 2020 election were pointed to a federal election website instead of getting an answer. It did the same for 2024 and for 2022 Senate races. Users in France or Canada got direct answers. Google's Gemini app, ChatGPT, and Claude all name Joe Biden. The behavior changed only after public outcry, with the midterms days away.
- The claim
- Google blamed a technical gap with the 2020 results.
- Austin's take
- Austin thinks it looks more like a bug than something nefarious, possibly a leftover guardrail in an older model behind a free tool. He credits public pushback for getting it fixed, recommends paid AI tiers for better results, and urges everyone to stay skeptical and check the sources AI Mode links to.
- Why it matters
- Millions now get facts from AI answers, and inconsistent handling of basic election results right before the midterms erodes trust in those tools.
- What to do
- Test it yourself to see if it is fixed, and treat AI answers on elections and other high stakes facts as a starting point. Click through to the cited sources.
- Not confirmed yet
- Whether this was a bug or an intentional guardrail is not established; Austin is speculating when he calls it a bug.
- Sources
From the Thursday, October 29 show
Google's AI Mode wouldn't say who won 2020 for US users
AI-generated from the transcript