- What happened
- OpenAI announced on Monday a proof that breaks a decades-old computer science rule saying some puzzles get hopelessly slow as they grow, a rule hundreds of research papers assume holds. OpenAI also claims proofs in physics and pure math. Anthropic says Claude found a similar proof in its own separate study. Both say unreleased in-house models did the work, and both posted computer-checked versions anyone can inspect. Two scientists behind the original rule will help lead OpenAI's review. No human has finished checking either proof.
- The claim
- Both companies say their unreleased internal models produced the proofs. Anthropic says the result won't speed up any real-world work.
- Austin's take
- Austin thinks this is phenomenal and a precursor to bigger breakthroughs like medicine, even if near-term real-world impact is probably small. He flags the bottleneck: if humans must slowly verify AI discoveries, how much does it really speed science up? He also wonders whether the near-simultaneous announcements are coincidence or competition, and says he wouldn't yet trust a proof no human has checked.
- Why it matters
- If the proofs hold, AI is producing discoveries top experts missed, and a lot of existing research built on the old rule would need revisiting.
- What to do
- Treat both claims as pending until the human reviews finish. Watch for the results of the OpenAI review led in part by the rule's original authors.
- Not confirmed yet
- Neither proof has been fully checked by humans yet, so the claims are unconfirmed.
From the Tuesday, October 27 show
OpenAI and Anthropic both claim AI-found proofs breaking a famous computer science rule
AI-generated from the transcript