- What happened
- A federal appeals court removed Judge Henry Wingate from a case after his order blocking Mississippi's ban on DEI in public schools named people not in the case and misquoted the law. Even the corrected version cited a court case that doesn't exist. Judge Jerry Smith called the proceedings a botched job, and the court also said Wingate got the law wrong.
- The claim
- Wingate called the errors clerical and said a law clerk's AI draft got filed by mistake.
- Austin's take
- Austin says legal work needs tools built and trained for specific jurisdictions, plus humans checking every output. Ron argues the real problem was that nobody disclosed AI use, and Austin agrees courts should disclose when AI helped.
- Why it matters
- Judges' offices use AI too, and a sloppy draft can decide a real person's case.
- What to do
- If you use AI for legal documents like NDAs, read the full output and verify every citation. Push for disclosure when AI is used in rulings.
- Not confirmed yet
- It's unclear how much of the error came from the AI versus the judge himself, since the court also faulted his reading of the law.
From the Friday, October 23 show
Federal judge pulled off a case over AI made errors
AI-generated from the transcript