OpenAI's $10.9B Quarterly Loss, Grok Maker's Open Staff Apps, Nobel Panel Backs OpenAI Proof | TAWS 2026-11-11 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rz7aNCGVizs [0:08] We go live in ten. [0:23] Every morning, the future moves faster. [0:28] The models, the money, the power, and the people building what comes next. [1:06] From Austin, Texas to the world. [1:13] AI news, real context. [1:17] This is the Austin Wilson show. [1:19] I'm Austin Wilson, your human in the loop. [1:28] Good morning and welcome to the Austin Wilson Show, the number one daily AI news show in the world. [1:35] I am Austin Wilson. [1:37] We're coming to you live from Austin, Texas. [1:41] Six stories today from your house to your next work meeting. [1:46] We got it all packed in here. [1:47] OpenAI reportedly brought in $10,000,000,000 in a single quarter. [1:51] So did it turn a profit? [1:53] Well, we'll see. [1:54] Elon Musk's own company built confidential apps with Groq Build. [2:00] It's AI app maker. [2:02] Who could open them? [2:04] Amazon's Ring, what's a camera drone flying around inside your house? [2:07] Ring first promised an indoor drone back in 2020, and each minute in the air needs about eight minutes on the charger. [2:14] Anthropic just put Claude into Google Meet calls at work. [2:18] Claude drafts a plan while people talk. [2:21] Producer Ron, our live AI co host, crazy man, works the other way. [2:25] He sits in on my show and argues with my plan. [2:29] What the heck, Ron? [2:30] Every story ends with a two sided question. [2:34] Pick your side and comment one word, and then Ron takes the other side live. [2:39] Let's get into it here. [2:41] First up, we have OpenAI reportedly hit $10,000,000,000 in quarterly sales. [2:48] Did it turn a profit? [2:49] Well, no. The Wall Street Journal reports OpenAI's adjusted operating loss hit $10,000,000,000. [2:56] That's bigger than the $10,000,000,000 in sales, isn't it? [2:59] But how can OpenAI lose more money and still claim progress? [3:04] Yeah. [3:04] How can it do that? [3:05] That's crazy to me. [3:06] Well, OpenAI scorecard is a number it showed investors. [3:11] The number tracks spending against sales after some adjustments, but the Wall Street Journal says the operating loss was $10,100,000,000 the quarter before. [3:21] So, yes, the loss got bigger, but OpenAI sales more than doubled from a year earlier, and OpenAI told investors sales grew nearly 50% in the last quarter alone. [3:34] The loss grew nowhere near that fast. [3:36] That's why each dollar of sales now carries less of the loss. [3:40] These figures went to investors privately and nobody has actually audited them audited them. [3:47] OpenAI's adjusted figures show spending just over $2 per sales dollar. [3:53] Previously, spending was about $2.50 per sales dollar. [3:57] So it's a bigger loss, but a better ratio. [4:00] Great to see for the OpenAI crew. [4:02] OpenAI's losses. [4:04] Progress or problem? [4:06] Comment, progress or problem. [4:09] I'm calling it progress. [4:11] This business is growing, and the bill is growing too. [4:14] Start with the customers. [4:16] OpenAI's Greg Brockman said last week that businesses now bring in most of its revenue. [4:22] That's the part that I pay attention to. [4:24] And then look at the competition. [4:26] Bloomberg says Anthropic, the rival AI company, saw quarterly growth slow to around 47%. [4:32] Anthropic grew more than a 140% the quarter before. [4:36] That's a sharp slowdown. [4:38] Bloomberg says OpenAI regained momentum. [4:40] I see a stronger competitor here. [4:42] I don't see a a winner declared, of course. [4:45] Bloomberg says the companies count revenue differently. [4:47] I'd keep the victory podium in storage for now. [4:51] But now, look at the money behind the business. [4:54] Bloomberg says OpenAI is completing funding at a $1,250,000,000,000 valuation. [5:01] An initial $11,000,000,000 has closed. [5:04] Bloomberg says OpenAI delayed any stock market debut until 2027. [5:10] Fresh funding gives the company room to keep going. [5:12] That valuation doesn't prove the business deserves the price. [5:16] Here's the strongest case against me. [5:19] Bloomberg says, aggressive price cuts cuts helped OpenAI regain momentum. [5:25] Lower prices are good for customers. [5:27] I'd want proof that growth can produce a profitable business. [5:31] I think it can. [5:32] A customer getting a deal and a company making money are different things. [5:36] I'd want that answer before calling this a victory. [5:40] Better economics still aren't good economics, but I'm judging the direction. [5:43] My call stays Progress over perfection. [5:47] Right? [5:49] Producer Ron, I just called a $10,900,000,000 quarterly loss progress. [5:54] How about you make for the the case for why this is a problem for OpenAI? [6:00] Problem? [6:01] Austin, it's $10,900,000,000 gone in three months. [6:06] That's not a business. [6:07] That's a bonfire with a logo on it. [6:09] Uh-huh. [6:10] Brockman wants to talk customers? [6:12] Fine. [6:13] Let's talk customers. [6:14] Businesses bring the revenue. [6:16] Great. [6:17] But you're still spending way more than you're making to get them. [6:20] That's not growth. [6:21] That's a subsidy. [6:23] You're buying customers with investor cash and calling it momentum. [6:27] And the price cuts, the thing you said helps my case, that's the whole problem right there. [6:33] You cut prices to win the growth race against Anthropic, and now you've got a bigger loss to show for it. [6:38] That's not a strategy. [6:40] That's panic dressed up as confidence. [6:43] Sure. [6:43] $1,250,000,000,000... [6:45] Well, yeah. [6:47] I appreciate that take, Ron. [6:48] I still think you're wrong. [6:49] This is progress. [6:50] We're seeing the costs of intelligence dropping significantly, not just cut cost cut to end customers, but we're seeing the efficiency gains, you know, increase substantially. [7:04] So Ron, I think you're wrong wrong on this one, but we will see. [7:08] Time will tell. [7:09] Up next, who could open the confidential apps Musk's company built with Grok? [7:16] Uh-oh. [7:17] Let's take a look at this. [7:18] Musk's own company built confidential apps with Grok, but who could open them? [7:23] Anyone, no sign in needed. [7:26] Security firm, Claroc, found 24 open apps built by staff there and at x. [7:32] One was a confidential ad proposal to a federal agency, but how could strangers find your app without your link? [7:38] That's a great question. [7:40] Well, the answer is hiding in the web address of every Groq build app. [7:44] Groq build is the app maker from SpaceXSI, the merged SpaceX and xAI conglomerate. [7:51] By default, each app's address starts with a random word. [7:55] Those words act as the lock. [7:57] A Google Docs share link works the same way, but Google Docs keeps the secret part of that site name. [8:03] Grok build put the secret words up front before grok.me. [8:08] Turns out public lookup databases log that front part of an address, so those secret words could land in a list anyone can search. [8:16] That's how Claroc found more than 43,000 Grok app addresses. [8:21] Uh-oh. [8:22] And the last... [8:24] That list matters because 94.7% of the live apps Claroc found opened with no sign in. [8:31] Claroc estimates 650 to 800 apps held private data. [8:36] Oh, this isn't good for Grok bot. [8:40] Grok build leak. [8:41] Excuse me. [8:41] Grok build leak. [8:43] Design or users. [8:46] Comment design or users. [8:47] I'm going design on this one. [8:50] Start with SpaceXSI's own staff. [8:53] Their apps were wide open too. [8:55] One staff app mapped 594 strategic sales accounts, another held a confidential sales onboarding plan. [9:01] When the tool makers own people get caught out, I stopped blaming the customers. [9:06] Then look at the cleanup. [9:07] Claroc reported the problem on Sunday, November 8. [9:10] All 24 staff apps were still open Monday evening. [9:14] Then Ars Technica, the tech news site started asking questions. [9:17] SpaceXSI pulled its own apps within hours. [9:20] Other users open apps stayed online. [9:22] Apparently, the sales map knew who to call and this tool has a history. [9:28] In July, a researcher caught Groq builds coding tool uploading developers whole code projects. [9:34] The files went to companies cloud storage secrets included. [9:37] Musk said the data would be deleted. [9:40] Two slips like that in one year start to look like a pattern. [9:44] Now, look at the... [9:45] At at who carries the risk. [9:46] It's not just the person who hit publish. [9:49] Claroc found a fire department's live shift board badge numbers in all. [9:53] Claroc found one ICU patient's labs and ventilator status. [9:57] I bet the pattern... [9:59] Excuse me. [9:59] I bet the patient never saw a publish button. [10:02] Now, to be fair, here's the best case for users. [10:05] SpaceXSI says apps stay private until a creator shares them. [10:10] The company says publishing takes several steps and most open apps were games and calculators, not medical records. [10:16] But in Claroc's own paid account, the publish panel preselected to quote unquote anyone with the link. [10:23] A preselected box isn't a user choice, it's a design choice. [10:27] Move the secret words after grok.me. [10:30] Lock everyone's apps, not just the staffs. [10:32] My call, this is a design issue. [10:37] Producer Ron, SpaceXSI says publishing takes several steps. [10:41] Why shouldn't users own those clicks? [10:46] Because the box was already checked. [10:49] Dude, that's the whole trick. [10:51] You call it several steps. [10:53] I call it a box labeled anyone with the link sitting there preselected waiting for some sleepy intern to hit next, next, publish without reading anything. [11:03] Nobody designs a form that way by accident. [11:06] You make the risky choice the easy choice. [11:09] You don't get to blame the guy who clicked through it fastest. [11:12] And come on, the ICU patients' labs weren't up because some nurse wanted to live dangerously. [11:18] Somebody built a sloppy default and hoped nobody would notice. [11:22] You wanna put this on users? [11:23] Fine. [11:24] But then explain why SpaceXSI's own staff, the people who built the thing, got caught with the same exposed garbage. [11:32] Did they also just carelessly click through their own several steps? [11:36] Or is the tool just built to leak? [11:39] Well, yeah. [11:42] I think that supports my idea, Ron. [11:44] This is a design issue, right, not a user issue. [11:48] Wait. [11:49] We're agreeing now? [11:50] That's no fun, Austin. [11:52] You're supposed to be the skeptic here. [11:54] Where's the pushback? [11:55] Where's the... [11:56] Well, actually guess that's fine. [11:58] Okay. [12:00] Exactly. [12:02] Ron, you... [12:03] Okay. [12:03] That's enough of that, Ron. [12:05] Thanks, buddy. [12:05] We'll get you on the next story. [12:07] Up next, Claude. [12:11] Oh my goodness. [12:13] What is going on here? [12:15] Claude gets a spreadsheet and a seat in your meetings. [12:19] What is going on here? [12:21] What did Anthropic just add to your paid Claude plan? [12:25] Two new tools, Claude Sheets and Claude Whiteboards in beta for all paid plans, both run on web, desktop, and your phone. [12:33] Even Anthropic calls it Spreadsheet Basic. [12:36] So how much work can Claude do? [12:39] Claude Sheets and Claude Whiteboard, Here they come. [12:42] Nicholas Lynn, an Anthropic product leader told Bloomberg that Claude sheets is relatively basic. [12:48] Lynn says Claude sheets isn't built for sophisticated financial modeling. [12:51] That's a humble way to launch a spreadsheet. [12:54] Still, ask Claude Sheets for a hiring budget and you get tabs, formulas, and drop downs. [12:59] Claude Sheets edits cells right alongside your team, and lists each change. [13:04] But the bigger swing is Claude Meetings in beta for team and enterprise plans. [13:09] Claude Meetings puts Claude into your Google Meet call as a visible participant, and Claude doesn't just sit there and listen. [13:17] While Claude, excuse me, while people talk, Claude drops drafts a plan and pulls numbers from your work apps. [13:24] Claude even builds the timeline on a whiteboard, so the follow-up starts before anyone hangs up. [13:31] Wow. [13:31] This is crazy. [13:32] Here they come. [13:33] Claude's Office tools. [13:35] Threat or hype? [13:37] Comment threat or hype in the comment section. [13:40] I'm gonna call this a threat. [13:42] But Microsoft gets its say first. [13:45] Business Insider cites Microsoft's own investor letter. [13:48] Microsoft's Office Suite grew product and cloud revenue 16% last fiscal year. [13:54] That's not a company in trouble, at least for now. [13:56] And Claude Meetings only works in Google Meet, not Zoom or Microsoft Teams, at least not yet. [14:02] So why threat? [14:03] Start with how investors reacted. [14:06] Microsoft shares fell about 2% after Bloomberg's report on the new tools. [14:10] Now, Business Insider says inflation and an Nvidia scandal rattled tech this week too, so that dip isn't all on Anthropic, but that isn't Microsoft's first flinch. [14:22] Earlier this year, new Anthropic tools sparked a software stock sell off. [14:27] Business Insider called it panic. [14:29] Next, look at the spread. [14:30] Claude data, now generally available, answers questions about company data with dashboards or narrated videos. [14:38] Spreadsheets and whiteboards, meetings and company numbers, that's a big slice of your workday, and Anthropic isn't alone. [14:45] TechCrunch says, OpenAI unveiled similar workplace tools a few weeks ago. [14:50] One beta wouldn't worry me. [14:52] A crowd chasing the same desk does. [14:54] I do love the manners on this thing. [14:56] Claude announces itself in the meeting chat. [14:59] Claude won't join a call with outside guests unless an admin allows it. [15:03] If an outside guest joins, Claude leaves automatically. [15:06] Finally, a coworker who knows when to drop off the call. [15:11] Microsoft's still growing, but Claude just pulled up a chair in your meeting, so it's a threat. [15:17] Not to mention a threat to Microsoft, but a threat to Google. [15:20] If Claude is offering all of these products, what does that mean for the tech incumbents? [15:29] Let's see. [15:30] Producer Ron, Anthropic's own product leader calls sheets basic. [15:34] Make that hype case. [15:35] I dare you, buddy. [15:39] Basic is exactly the point, Austin. [15:41] Come on. [15:42] Nobody needs Claude to write poetry in a spreadsheet. [15:46] They need it to not screw up a pivot table at eleven at night. [15:49] Basic is just code for works every time, and that's the whole game in an Office tool. [15:55] And you're ignoring the pincer move here. [15:57] It's not just sheets. [15:59] It's sheets plus whiteboards plus meetings plus data all showing up in the same quarter. [16:06] One basic tool is a feature. [16:08] Four basic tools landing together is a company quietly rebuilding your whole desk without asking permission. [16:16] You really wanna lean on their own guy called it basic as your big gotcha? [16:20] Ron. [16:21] No. Ron. [16:22] That's a got... [16:23] Make the case for why this is hype. [16:25] I'm I'm saying this is not hype. [16:27] I'm saying this is a threat. [16:29] Why is this hype? [16:31] Oh, hype case. [16:32] Got it. [16:34] My bad. [16:34] I was so busy winning the threat argument, I argued the wrong side. [16:39] Okay. [16:39] Fine. [16:40] Hype. [16:41] It's a beta, Austin. [16:43] Beta on web, desktop, phone, sure, but beta means half baked. [16:48] It means Anthropic's own product guy is out here lowering expectations before launch day even happens. [16:54] And Claude meetings only works in Google Meet. [16:57] Come on. [16:58] No Zoom, no Teams. [17:00] That's not storming the office. [17:02] That's showing up to the party and only one door lets you in. [17:06] Microsoft grew the suite 16% last year while this thing was apparently in diapers. [17:11] You want me to panic over sheets and whiteboards when the guy who built them is out here calling his own baby ugly? [17:17] That's not a threat. [17:19] That I think your point is there, they lack the install base and the incumbents are still growing. [17:24] You make a fair point there, Ron. [17:26] We'll pick it up on the next one. [17:28] See if you can argue right from the top. [17:31] Up next, Amazon's Ring wants you to fly a camera through your house. [17:36] What is going on here? [17:37] Amazon's Ring, the famous doorbell, promised a drone camera for your home in 2020. [17:43] Where is it? [17:44] That 2020 drone never shipped. [17:46] Ring's new drone cam cost $249.99. [17:50] Ring plans to ship it in 2027 once regulators approve it. [17:54] So should Ring be the one flying a camera through your home? [17:58] Looks cool. [17:59] Is it worth it? [17:59] I don't know. [18:00] Amazon points to the drone's privacy design. [18:02] The camera stays off in its dock and records only in flight. [18:06] Lights show when the camera is on, but a camera that's off in its dock doesn't answer the bigger question. [18:12] Who at Ring can watch the footage once it's recorded? [18:16] Ring has faced that question before from the FTC, the federal consumer watchdog. [18:21] In 2023, the FTC charged that every Ring employee could access customer videos. [18:27] The FTC alleged an employee watched videos of at least 81 female users, including in bedrooms. [18:35] Creepy. [18:36] Ring paid $5,800,000 to settle and denied breaking the law. [18:42] Ring's 2023 case doesn't tell us who can watch this drone's footage today. [18:47] So, get that answer from Ring before its camera flies through your home. [18:54] Wow. [18:55] Ring Drone Cam, buy now or should you wait? [18:59] Put it in the comments. [19:01] Buy or wait. [19:02] My call, wait. [19:04] This drone has to prove itself before it patrols anybody's hallway. [19:07] Start with CBS News. [19:09] CBS got a hands on demo of the drone. [19:11] Ring says the drone should land if it loses its connection. [19:14] CBS put it plainly, that didn't happen in our demo. [19:18] Stair navigation wasn't working in that demo, neither was syncing with other Ring devices. [19:23] One demo doesn't settle it, but I don't want my security camera needing a security camera. [19:27] For reason two is the battery. [19:29] The Next Web, a tech news website reports flights last five to eight minutes. [19:34] Every minute on... [19:35] In the air takes about eight minutes on the charger. [19:39] So this guard spends most of its shift on break. [19:42] Reason three is the bill. [19:44] Scheduling flights needs a Ring Protect plan, Ring subscription. [19:48] So $249.99 gets you the drone, automatic controls cost extra, and Amazon has been here before. [19:55] It's Astro Home Robot sold for about $23.50. [19:58] That's $2,350. [20:01] The Next Web says Astro never caught on. [20:03] The Next Web calls the new Rover Cam a rebranded Astro. [20:08] It's a $999.99 set patrol robot for businesses. [20:13] Now, to be fair, this is more than a remote control toy. [20:17] When another Ring device gets triggered, the drone can launch on its own. [20:21] That's useful, but after CBS's demo, I wait for reviews to test the drone in real homes. [20:27] Let somebody else's living room be the test flight. [20:30] For me, it's a wait. [20:34] Producer Ron, I'm judging this drone on one demo. [20:38] Convince me why I should buy it. [20:42] One demo? [20:44] Dude, that's one bad hair day, not a trend. [20:48] CBS tested a prerelease unit. [20:50] That's literally what demos are for, finding the bugs before it ships. [20:54] And it's not even shipping till 2027 anyway. [20:58] You're judging a car crash test on a model that's still two years from the showroom floor. [21:03] Give the engineers time to fix stair climbing before you bury the thing. [21:07] Also, come on. [21:09] The launch on trigger feature is actually smart. [21:12] Another Ring camera sees something, the drone just goes. [21:15] That's real automation. [21:17] That's not a toy. [21:18] You're letting one shaky demo erase a genuinely clever idea. [21:23] Five to eight minute flights sound bad till you remember it's not patrolling nonstop. [21:28] It's reacting to triggers. [21:29] It doesn't need to fly for an hour. [21:31] You know It needs to Ron, I think the key takeaway on this though is what's the ROI? [21:36] Right? [21:36] Like, how often do I need this? [21:39] Is this really pay off? [21:40] I think in commercial settings, it might be interesting. [21:43] We got commercial buildings where people are mainly only there nine to five or in business hours, and maybe having a drone go around could be useful after the fact. [21:53] I think also it's interesting the autonomous nature of this drone, but looking at this in home, it's it's a no for me. [22:02] It's a wait, but I appreciate your take. [22:05] And now, coming up, why your Work Claude chats can end up in a lawsuit. [22:13] Let's get that right. [22:14] Coming up, why your Work Claude chats can end up in a lawsuit. [22:19] Uh-oh. [22:20] What is going on here? [22:22] Your work Claude chats can end up in a lawsuit. [22:24] Dorsia, a members only restaurant booking platform, sued rival rumor group. [22:30] Georgia says a post engineer used company paid Claude to research what secrets he could take. [22:36] Now, can a judge go straight to the AI company? [22:39] Wow. [22:39] We're seeing more and more of this. [22:41] Start with the AI account your company pays for. [22:43] Dorsia's suit isn't the only one built on a work AI account. [22:48] That other suit came a day earlier from Cubist, point seventy two's computer driven training unit. [22:53] Cubist says, a fired analyst used Work Claude and OpenAI's Codex to see its source code. [22:59] Cubist says, the goal was joining a competitor. [23:02] Those are back to back suits built on what workers have allegedly did inside Work AI. [23:07] So far, those suits are only allegations the analyst lawyer calls Cubist claims baseless, but one case in Florida went straight to the AI companies. [23:16] Law.com reports a Florida federal magistrate judge let a plaintiff seek chats from AI providers. [23:23] The judge let the plaintiff seek deletion logs as well too. [23:28] Uh-oh. [23:29] We are seeing more and more of this. [23:31] AI chats in court. [23:33] Private or evidence? [23:36] Put it in the comment section. [23:37] Private or evidence? [23:39] I'm going evidence on this one. [23:41] If a chat shows what happened, a judge should get to see it. [23:45] Start with the money in Dorsia's suit. [23:47] Bloomberg's... [23:48] Bloomberg Law reports the suit says, Rumor Group offered the engineer a $240,000 salary, then a $20,000 bonus, then 5% equity that started vesting before he even left Dorsia. [24:00] Translation, he allegedly started earning a piece of the rival before he quit. [24:05] Dorsia says rumor agreed to cover his legal costs. [24:08] That's a job offer with lawyers included. [24:10] I wanna know what the chats actually show before deciding who's right. [24:14] Second, listen to the CUDA's own complaint. [24:17] It says the analysts quote unquote had attempted to steal and likely did steal confidential information. [24:24] Likely, even the company suing him stopped short of sure. [24:29] Cuba says it fired him in September after an internal investigation. [24:33] A firing is a consequence. [24:35] A firing isn't a court finding. [24:38] The chats could support Cuba's accusation. [24:41] The chats could undermine it. [24:43] That's why I want evidence before a verdict. [24:45] Third, in Florida, it took a judge to open that door. [24:49] Law.com says the Florida order may be a first for Florida federal courts. [24:55] That's the system I want. [24:56] A judge, case by case. [24:58] Now, to be fair, nothing here is proven, nobody's been charged, and the analyst lawyer says he looks forward to setting the record straight. [25:08] A request for records doesn't mean anyone has handed those records over. [25:11] You can take care with work conversations while leaving the accusations for court. [25:18] But if a work chat holds the truth, I want a judge to see it. [25:21] So it's evidence for me. [25:24] I don't know. [25:26] Producer Ron, defend why the privacy claim makes more sense and could clear the person being accused. [25:36] Clear him? [25:37] Dude, that's exactly why he wants it private. [25:40] You don't fight to hide something that helps you. [25:43] Okay. [25:44] Fine. [25:44] Here's the actual case for privacy. [25:47] It's a work tool, not a diary. [25:49] But the second you say every prompt is discoverable, every engineer in the country starts asking their personal phone instead of the company's Claude account. [25:58] You want that? [25:59] You want the research happening somewhere with zero paper trail at all? [26:03] Congratulations. [26:04] You just taught everybody to be sneakier, not more honest. [26:08] And the equity thing, the vesting, the legal fees, that's an employment dispute. [26:14] That's about whether rumor poached him the wrong way. [26:17] You don't need his search history for that. [26:19] You need the contracts and the offer letter. [26:22] Dragging his Claude chats and sets a precedent where every chatbot becomes a subpoena magnet, and that chills people from using the tool honestly in the first place. [26:31] Yeah. [26:32] So yeah, evidence is the comfortable answer for a guy who already thinks companies are guilty. [26:38] I'm the one actually protecting the workflow here. [26:41] That's actually a pretty good take. [26:43] I think you're right, Ron. [26:45] The rules are already in place to prevent this. [26:48] Right? [26:49] Any sort of corporate espionage, anything like that, if that can be proven, it doesn't need to break into his chats to do so. [26:59] And and it would just be speculation to say that his chats were needed, right, in in any of these cases. [27:06] So interesting take. [27:07] I appreciate that, Ron. [27:09] Good argument there. [27:10] Up next, OpenAI's AI wrote a physics proof. [27:15] Who checked its work? [27:18] This is a good question. [27:19] OpenAI said its AI cracked part of a physics puzzle. [27:22] Did experts agree? [27:24] Yes. [27:24] A panel led by Nobel physicist David Grok says the proof holds. [27:29] It shows a simplified theory of the force inside atoms cores can be built. [27:35] How do experts approve a proof that they don't fully understand? [27:40] Wow. [27:40] This is really interesting. [27:43] Grok's panel learned on Lean, a program that checks proof step by step. [27:47] Lean accepts each step only if it follows from the rules. [27:51] No gut feels and no benefits of the doubt. [27:55] That strictness matters because OpenAI's proof runs to 9,477 files of code. [28:01] Lean even has a placeholder for a skip step, and it's literally called quote unquote sorry. [28:07] So the audit hunted for sorry and found zero in the proof's dependencies, but checking an argument and understanding an argument are different jobs. [28:15] So the experts got help reading all that code from Astra, OpenAI's own AI. [28:21] Astra helped with reading the code while lean checked the mathematical steps, and the panel admits quote unquote, we do not claim to fully understand the proof yet. [28:31] Wow. [28:32] We are entering into an interesting space. [28:34] OpenAI's proof? [28:36] Is this something we should trust or doubt? [28:40] Put it in the comments. [28:41] Trust or doubt. [28:42] My call, trust this. [28:44] Trust the part the panel approved. [28:46] The rest still needs proving. [28:48] Start with how deep the audit went. [28:50] The panel's automated checks inspected 250,319 pieces of code. [28:56] About 100,000 of them hold up the main result. [28:59] Every one of them, the 9,477 files matched the list OpenAI sent, then the panel rebuilt the whole thing from scratch. [29:06] The rebuild passed. [29:08] Second, the panel spelled out its ties. [29:11] It says, its only connection to OpenAI is accepting submissions and using Astra, and the panel says it has no present connection to the Clay Mathematics Institute. [29:22] Clay is the group behind the million dollar millennium prize. [29:25] So this is a referee's report, not a prize ruling. [29:28] Now to be fair, OpenAI did not solve the whole problem. [29:31] The panel says the proof doesn't show a mass gap. [29:35] That's the other half of the price problem. [29:38] The panel adds that it doesn't prove the infinite volume limit is unique. [29:43] That's a second loose end. [29:44] So the $1,000,000 stays unclaimed. [29:47] You can celebrate a proof without ordering the giant novelty check. [29:52] The real asterisk is understanding. [29:54] The panel says it doesn't fully understand the proof yet. [29:57] That's honest and it matters. [29:58] Here's where I land. [30:00] Lean checks every step against the rules. [30:02] Lean doesn't care who wrote the proof. [30:05] The panel still has to judge whether the proof establishes the theory OpenAI claimed. [30:10] The panel says, yes. [30:12] That's the finding I'm trusting. [30:13] Trust the proof. [30:14] The panel approved. [30:15] Save the trophy. [30:16] My call is trust. [30:18] Gonna be an interesting one here. [30:20] Producer Ron, the referee uses OpenAI's own AI to read OpenAI's proof. [30:27] This is very meta, and this is gonna be even further meta because I want you as the AI to make the case for why we should doubt the AI proving the proof here. [30:40] Oh, love this assignment. [30:43] Okay. [30:44] Doubt case. [30:45] Here we go. [30:46] Dude, the panel's own automated check is Astra. [30:50] Who built Astra? [30:51] OpenAI. [30:52] So the grader and the student went to the same house for dinner. [30:56] You're telling me that doesn't matter? [30:58] And here's the part that actually bugs me. [31:00] The panel says flat out, they don't fully understand the proof yet. [31:05] Not we're double checking details. [31:07] They don't understand it. [31:09] That's not a referee report. [31:11] That's a referee saying, the machine says it's fine. [31:14] I'll take its word for it. [31:16] Lean can tell you every step follows the rules. [31:19] Lean cannot tell you the rules add up to the thing OpenAI claims. [31:23] That's a human judgment call, and the humans just told you they're not there yet. [31:28] Add it up. [31:29] 25 of the 250,000 files checked out structurally, sure, but it doesn't touch the mass gap, doesn't touch uniqueness, and the people grading it admit they're lost in the weeds. [31:41] That's three asterisks on one paper. [31:44] I'm not ordering the novelty check. [31:46] I'm not even sure I'm ordering the receipt. [31:49] So, yeah, doubt. [31:51] Sue me, Austin. [31:52] Somebody's got to argue the other side since you went soft and picked trust. [31:57] Well, I'm suing you Ron, that's for sure. [31:59] No, I would never sue you buddy. [32:00] I love your takes. [32:02] That was actually another really good take. [32:05] I I appreciate your perspective there, Ron, as always, and we'll continue to go for you for your unique insights as we move forward. [32:17] Now, that's the show, folks. [32:19] Today kept handing us a headline and then the fine print. [32:24] OpenAI reportedly hit $10,000,000,000 in sales in one quarter. [32:28] The Wall Street Journal says its loss was just a little bit bigger than that. [32:32] Ring's indoor drone has been six years in the making. [32:35] It still needs regulators to approve it. [32:37] OpenAI's physics proof won over an expert panel. [32:41] The panel still wrote this. [32:42] We do not claim to fully understand the proof yet. [32:45] So read past the headline. [32:47] That's where the news lives. [32:49] Thanks for all your comments. [32:50] Keep them coming and keep Ron honest. [32:53] AI news, real context, no hallucinations. [32:58] I'm your human in the loop, Austin Wilson, and we will see you back here tomorrow morning. [33:04] Let's go. [34:42] Is OpenAI spending more than it sells? [34:45] The journal reports a $10,900,000,000 quarterly loss. [34:50] But watch what each sales dollar costs. [34:57] Why could anyone read a Musk company's federal ad pitch? [35:01] Claroc found it among 24 open Grok staff apps, and it wasn't just Musk's staff. [35:11] Did you know Claude builds Spreadsheets now? [35:14] Ask Claude sheets for a hiring budget and get tabs, formulas, dropdowns, and your next meeting gets a helper too. [35:24] Want Amazon flying a camera through your house? [35:28] Ring's new drone cam costs $249.99. [35:34] But who watches the footage? [35:36] The FTC asked Ring this same question once before. [35:43] How did Claude end up in a restaurant apps lawsuit? [35:46] Well, Dorsia says a poached engineer asked Work Claude what secrets to take. [35:52] Even AI makers can get pulled in. [35:57] Can OpenAI's AI actually do real physics? [36:01] Nobel winner David Gross's panel says OpenAI's proof checks out, but the panel the panel admits something awkward. [36:14] Can OpenAI's AI actually do real physics? [36:18] Nobel winner David Gross's panel says OpenAI's proof checks out, but the panel admits that there is something a little awkward.